Advertisement
The light turns red, you stop, and a second later a pickup slams into your rear bumper. The other driver is apologetic, even friendly, until you ask for his insurance card and he admits the policy lapsed a couple of months ago when money got tight. Your neck is stiff, your trunk will not close and the person who caused all of it has no insurer to send the bill to and very little money of his own.
This is the situation uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage was designed for. Instead of chasing someone who cannot pay, you file with your own insurer, which steps into the role the other driver’s insurer should have played. How much that protection is worth depends on the limits you choose, the rules where you live and a few policy conditions that are easy to overlook until you need them.
Advertisement
Why Your Own Liability Coverage Will Not Help
Many drivers assume that carrying good insurance protects them from any crash. It does protect other people from you, because liability coverage pays for the harm you cause. When someone else causes the harm, your recovery normally depends on their liability coverage, and if they have none or too little, your excellent liability limits do nothing for your injuries.
A meaningful share of drivers on the road carry no insurance at all, whether because a policy lapsed, was canceled or was never bought. Many more carry only the minimum the law requires, which can be exhausted by a single hospital stay or a totaled late-model vehicle. You cannot choose who hits you, so the quality of other drivers’ insurance is a risk you carry every time you pull out of the driveway.
Uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage shifts that risk back onto a policy you control. You pick the limits, you know the insurer and you know the claim will be handled under the terms of your own contract. That predictability is valuable when the alternative is a lawsuit against someone who may be unable to pay any judgment you win.
Uninsured and Underinsured Are Not the Same
Uninsured motorist coverage applies when the at-fault driver has no liability insurance, when the driver’s insurer denies coverage or becomes insolvent, and in many policies when the at-fault driver cannot be identified, as in a hit-and-run. It pays what you could have recovered from that driver’s liability policy, up to your uninsured limit.
Underinsured motorist coverage applies when the at-fault driver does have insurance but the limits fall short of your losses. Suppose your medical bills, lost income and other damages far exceed what the other driver’s policy can pay. Underinsured coverage fills the gap, up to your own limit, once the other driver’s coverage has been used up.
How that gap is calculated varies. Under some policies and local rules, underinsured coverage pays your full damages above what the at-fault driver’s insurer paid, up to your limit. Under others, your limit is reduced by the amount the at-fault driver’s insurer already paid, which means an underinsured limit equal to the other driver’s liability limit may add nothing at all. Ask your insurer which approach your policy uses, because it changes how high your limit needs to be.
A simple scenario shows why this detail matters. A cyclist commuting to work is struck by a driver carrying only the legal minimum, and her surgery, months away from her job and ongoing therapy cost far more than that minimum can pay. If her underinsured coverage pays on top of what the other insurer paid, her own limit becomes real extra money. If her limit is instead reduced by the other driver’s payment, a limit set too low could leave her with almost nothing beyond the minimum she already received.
The Injury Side and the Vehicle Side
The core of this coverage is bodily injury protection. It can pay medical bills, rehabilitation, lost wages and, where such claims are allowed, compensation for pain and suffering, just as the at-fault driver’s bodily injury liability would have. It generally protects you, relatives in your household and passengers in your car, and it often follows you as a pedestrian or cyclist struck by an uninsured vehicle.
Damage to your car is handled differently from place to place. Some policies offer uninsured motorist property damage coverage, which pays to repair your car when an identified uninsured driver is at fault, sometimes with a lower deductible than collision. In other places that option does not exist, and your collision coverage is the route to repairs, with your insurer later trying to recover the cost from the other driver.
If you carry collision and the property damage option is also offered, compare the two deductibles and conditions. Drivers with an older car and no collision coverage may find the property damage option the only protection they have for their vehicle when an uninsured driver causes a crash.
Hit-and-Run Crashes and the Proof They Demand
When the other driver flees, uninsured motorist coverage is often the only source of payment for injuries, but these claims draw close scrutiny because insurers must guard against staged or invented crashes. Policies commonly require that you report the crash to police within a short time and notify the insurer promptly. Some also require evidence of physical contact with the other vehicle, while others accept independent witness statements when there was no contact.
Evidence gathered at the scene carries a lot of weight. Photos of the damage and the road, paint transfer on your car, a partial plate number, video from a dash camera or a nearby business and the names of witnesses all help establish that another vehicle caused the crash. Write down what you remember about the fleeing car while it is fresh, including color, body style and direction of travel.
Delays hurt these claims more than most. A report filed days later, with no witnesses and no visible contact damage, gives the insurer grounds to question the account. Calling police from the scene, even when the other driver is long gone, is the single most useful step.
Claiming Against Your Own Insurer
An uninsured or underinsured claim has an unusual dynamic. Your insurer is paying on your behalf, but it evaluates the claim as if it were defending the at-fault driver, so the adjuster will question the severity of injuries and the connection between the crash and your treatment. It is still your insurer and must deal with you in good faith, but it is not simply writing a check on request.
Several policy conditions trip people up during these claims:
- Consent to settle: many policies require you to notify your insurer before accepting the at-fault driver’s limits, so it can protect its right to pursue that driver.
- Arbitration clauses: disputes over the value of the claim may go to arbitration rather than court, depending on the policy and local law.
- Deadlines: time limits for reporting and for starting legal action can be shorter than for ordinary injury lawsuits.
- Medical documentation: gaps in treatment or missed appointments are used to argue the injury was minor or unrelated.
For serious injuries, many people bring in a lawyer who handles injury claims, since the same valuation skills apply whether the payer is your insurer or someone else’s.
Required, Optional or Built In
Whether you must carry this coverage depends on where the car is registered. In some places uninsured motorist protection is mandatory. In others insurers must offer it and you can decline only by signing a written rejection. In some provinces, protection against uninsured drivers is part of the basic policy, and coverage for being hit by an underinsured driver is added through an optional endorsement that raises your limit.
A few places allow stacking, which lets you combine the uninsured limits for several vehicles on the same policy or across policies in your household. Stacking can multiply the available protection for a serious injury, usually at an added cost, and the rules on whether and how it works vary widely.
If you once signed a rejection form to save money, that choice may still be in effect years later. Check your declarations page for the coverage and its limits rather than assuming it is there. A quick call can confirm whether it was declined, reduced or never added when you changed vehicles.
Matching the Coverage to Your Own Protection
A sensible starting point is to carry uninsured and underinsured limits equal to your own liability limits. The reasoning is simple: if you think your limits are the right amount to pay someone you injure, they are also a reasonable amount to protect yourself and your family when someone else does the injuring. Many insurers let you choose lower uninsured limits, but those savings are usually small compared with what the coverage can pay after a serious crash.
Review this coverage whenever you change liability limits, add a driver or buy a new vehicle, and check how it interacts with your health insurance, disability benefits and any accident benefits in your policy. The details of stacking, rejection forms and underinsured calculations are set by each state or province and by your contract, so ask your insurer to explain your version in plain terms. Knowing the answer now is far better than learning it from a driver whose policy lapsed last month.
Price is rarely the obstacle drivers expect. Because the coverage pays only when another driver is both at fault and short on insurance, it usually costs far less than collision, and raising the limit to match your liability limit often adds only a small amount to the premium. Ask for a quote with and without the increase before deciding the extra protection is out of reach.
